Cheesecake Factory Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake: Price & Calories (2026)
The layered peanut butter slice is the one to ask for by its full name, Cheesecake Factory Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake, at $11.95 to $13.50 a slice and 1,510 calories, because the other peanut butter slice on this menu is built completely differently. This one layers Reese's cups into Original cheesecake with fudge cake and caramel. The other one, Adam's Peanut Butter Cup Fudge Ripple, swirls peanut butter and caramel through the cheesecake instead. Same peanut butter idea, different cake, 260 calories apart. The slice range below comes from 12 official pickup menus checked on November 5, 2026, and the calories come from the brand's published guide.
Which peanut butter slice is which?
Two peanut butter slices sit on the cheesecake menu, and their names do half the confusing for you. Reese's is the layered one. Adam's is the swirled one. The official description for this slice reads: "Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups in Our Original Cheesecake with Layers of Delicious Fudge Cake and Caramel." Adam's, by contrast, is creamy cheesecake swirled with caramel, peanut butter, Butterfinger and Reese's cups. Layered means you cut through bands of fudge cake and cheesecake with cups in between. Swirled means the peanut butter runs through the cheesecake itself. The numbers follow the build:
| Reese's | Adam's | |
|---|---|---|
| Build | Reese's cups layered into Original cheesecake with fudge cake and caramel | Cheesecake swirled with caramel, peanut butter, Butterfinger and Reese's cups |
| Calories | 1,510 | 1,250 |
| Sugar | 121g | 94g |
| Sodium | 940mg | 750mg |
| Protein | 23g | 18g |
| Slice price | $11.95–$13.50 | $11.50–$12.95 |
Read the pair as a choice, not a ranking. Reese's costs 260 calories more than Adam's and runs a slightly higher price range, $11.95 to $13.50 against Adam's $11.50 to $12.95. What you get for that is the fudge cake layers and the cups themselves, plus more protein at 23g against 18g. What you give up is nothing on sugar: Reese's has 121g against Adam's 94g, so the peanut butter hit is stronger here in every direction, including the 940mg of sodium.
How much does a Reese's slice cost?
A slice costs $11.95 to $13.50, with a median of $13.50 across 12 official pickup menus checked on November 5, 2026. That median sits at the top of the range because seven of the twelve menus charge $13.50, including New York, San Francisco, Chicago, Los Angeles, Bellevue, Boston and Denver. Three menus charge $11.95, Atlanta, Dallas and Kansas City, and two sit in the middle at $12.95, Miami and Phoenix. One warning before you plan around any number you see elsewhere: official dine-in menus print cheesecake prices as a section range, not a per-slice price, so a section range is not this slice's price. The range on this page is the per-slice range from the pickup menus, and it is the number to plan around. Before you order, check for any cheesecake promo codes too, since a live deal can change what the slice actually costs.
| Source | Price |
|---|---|
| 12 official pickup menus, slice (range) | $11.95–$13.50 |
| 12-menu median, slice | $13.50 |
| A La Mode topping | +$2.50 extra, +400 cal |
| Hot Fudge topping | +$2.50 extra, +280 cal |
The toppings change the bill twice over. A La Mode adds $2.50 and 400 calories. Hot Fudge adds $2.50 and 280 calories. Order both and the slice alone reaches 2,190 calories, so the toppings are worth deciding on before they arrive, not after.
The 1,510 tie with Oreo, broken on salt and protein
Reese's shares its calorie count exactly with Oreo Dream Extreme Cheesecake: 1,510 each. The tie ends there. Reese's is the saltier slice by a clear margin, 940mg of sodium against Oreo's 800mg, and it is the saltiest of all five cheesecake slices on this site. It is also the highest in protein, 23g against Oreo's 15g, which is the most protein in any slice in the line. Sugar, the number most people expect to decide a tie like this, does not: Reese's has 121g against Oreo's 122g, a one-gram difference. The full slice from the guide: 1,510 calories, 850 calories from fat, 95g total fat, 44g saturated fat, 2g trans fat, 245mg cholesterol, 940mg sodium, 154g carbohydrates, 8g fiber, 121g sugar, 23g protein. So if salt is the number you watch, this slice is the one to notice. If protein is the number you watch, it is the best in the line. The nutrition guide lists every slice the same way, so the comparison above is easy to check there: cheesecake slice nutrition.
Is there a whole Reese's cake to buy?
The short answer is that the cake exists and its price does not, at least not in any source this page can verify. The official menu lists a 10-inch Reese's cake, but it shows no price for it. That leaves the slice as the only Reese's order with a verified number, which is why this page stops at the slice. A whole-cake price from a third-party site is not a substitute: the ones online disagree with each other, and none of them were read from an official menu. If a whole cake is what you need, the restaurant itself is the only source worth asking.
Can you order a gluten-free Reese's slice?
No. The fudge cake layers are wheat cake, so the slice as served is not gluten-free, and no gluten-free substitute version of this slice has been verified. The confusion usually comes from the candy: Reese's Peanut Butter Cups on their own are labeled gluten-free, but that label belongs to the candy, not to this slice. Peanut is the headline warning here instead, since the cups are in the name and in the description, so confirm with your server if peanut is a concern. This page lists no contains-list for the slice because none has been verified.
Frequently asked questions about Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake
Twelve official pickup menus price the slice at $11.95 to $13.50, and the median lands on the top end, $13.50, because seven of the twelve charge exactly that.
The official Summer 2026 nutrition guide puts this slice at 1,510 calories, a number it shares exactly with the Oreo Dream Extreme slice, and the tie breaks on salt: 940mg here against 800mg there.
Reese's layers Reese's cups into Original cheesecake with fudge cake and caramel, at 1,510 calories a slice. Adam's swirls peanut butter and caramel through the cheesecake instead, at 1,250 calories. Reese's is 260 calories more.
Both slices are 1,510 calories. Reese's is saltier at 940mg of sodium against Oreo's 800mg, and higher in protein at 23g against 15g. Sugar is nearly tied at 121g against 122g.
A 10-inch cake exists, but no whole-cake price has been verified, so this page covers the slice only. The restaurant is the only place with a real whole-cake number, since the official menu lists the 10-inch cake without a price.
No, because the fudge cake layers are wheat cake. The candy is labeled gluten-free, but that does not apply to the slice. No gluten-free substitute for this slice has been verified.
Each topping costs $2.50 extra. A La Mode adds 400 calories and Hot Fudge adds 280 calories, so a slice with both reaches 2,190 calories.
Reese's or Adam's: which peanut butter slice should you order?
Cups and fudge cake layers, built up instead of swirled through: that is the difference between this slice and Adam's, and it is the whole choice. At 1,510 calories this is the saltiest slice in the line, and the layered build is the point, so order it when the layers are what you want. Adam's is 260 calories lighter at a slightly lower price, with the peanut butter swirled through the cheesecake instead, so the swirl is the lighter order and the layers are the heavier one.